Written by:
For years, Spirit Airlines was the brand consumers loved to mock. Cramped seats. Endless fees. Chaotic travel experiences. Spirit became shorthand for the bare minimum consumers were willing to tolerate in exchange for a cheaper price.
Yet, when they filed for bankruptcy, consumers suddenly expressed concern about what its disappearance could mean for affordable travel.
That reaction reveals an important tension in consumer behavior. People might complain about low-cost brands, but they still want the option to choose them.
A lot of the conversation has focused on what it could mean for airline pricing. Without a major ultra-low-cost competitor in the market, airlines may face less pressure to keep fares low.
But here’s a consequence people aren’t talking about: Premium airlines could lose one of the most important tools they had to justify charging more.
For years, Spirit defined the lower boundary of the category. “Better than Spirit” became a meaningful benchmark that consumers were willing to pay more for. In many ways, Spirit helped premium players look premium. Without that contrast, those carriers may need to work harder to justify their higher price point.
That dynamic should sound familiar to anyone in CPG.
Private labels play a similar role on the shelf. They set the baseline against which branded products are judged. And ironically, the rise of private label may make strong brands more valuable. Not less.
Inflation pushed millions of shoppers toward private label over the last several years. In some categories, trial rates surged as consumers searched for ways to stretch household budgets. But Spirit’s story highlights an important distinction not to overlook: affordability and brand strength aren’t the same thing.
Spirit won on price. But price wasn’t enough to build the kind of loyalty, emotional connection, or trust required to withstand turbulence.
That should serve as a warning to CPG brands racing to compete on cost.
In today’s environment, affordability is increasingly table stakes. But when every player is chasing lower prices, brands risk downplaying the very things that make consumers choose them in the first place.
The brands most likely to win in the years ahead may not be the cheapest products on the shelf — but the ones that most clearly earn their premium.
Best,
Abby
Source(s):
What travelers need to know about Spirit Airlines’ bankruptcy
The Ultra-Low-Cost Airline Announced It Is Shutting Down – Business Insider
If Spirit Airlines is liquidated, here’s what might happen to the industry : NPR
Spirit Airlines 2.0: Pendulum Data Reveals How Creators Drove the Real Story